Compare destinations

York or Edinburgh?

Two places visitors weigh up, side by side. Every figure comes from our guides, the Met Office, National Rail or an event organizer, and we do not rank either one.

York guide · Edinburgh guide

York Minster seen over trees and rooftops from the city walls
York: York Minster seen over trees and rooftops from the city wallsPhoto: Chris Gorringe, CC BY-SA 2.0
The walls and towers of Edinburgh Castle under a blue sky
Edinburgh: The walls and towers of Edinburgh Castle under a blue skyPhoto: Peulle, CC BY 4.0
Fossgate, Castle, Fossgate and Walmgate
York: FossgatePhoto: Drkirstyross, CC BY-SA 3.0
Dugald Stewart Monument, Holyrood, Arthur's Seat & Calton Hill
Edinburgh: Dugald Stewart MonumentPhoto: Carlos Delgado, CC BY-SA 3.0

Who each place suits

outdoor-leaning

York

A walled cathedral city of medieval streets, Roman and Viking layers, and the railways.

Our guide covers 5 areas, with 61 sights, 88 places to eat and drink and 27 places to stay, and 4 theater venues in the directory.

Most common sight types we list: Church (9), Street (8), City gate (5).

59% of the 44 sights we tag are outdoor places and 41% are indoors, so it reads as outdoor-leaning.

Our York guide suggests 1 to 3 days; its sample plans run from half day to 2 days.

York guide Theater in York Events in York Weather by month Rainy-day ideas
mixed

Edinburgh

A castle on a volcanic rock, a medieval Old Town and a Georgian New Town.

Our guide covers 9 areas, with 119 sights, 214 places to eat and drink and 78 places to stay, and 12 theater venues in the directory.

Most common sight types we list: Gallery (11), Park (9), Church (8).

47% of the 91 sights we tag are outdoor places and 53% are indoors, so it reads as mixed.

Our Edinburgh guide suggests 2 to 4 days; its sample plans run from 1 day to 3 days.

Edinburgh guide Theater in Edinburgh Events in Edinburgh Weather by month Rainy-day ideas

Side by side

Facts only. Counts show how much our guides list, not how much exists. “Reported” means tagged on OpenStreetMap or a venue’s own page: check with the venue.

York and Edinburgh: counts from our guides, climate averages and events.
ItemYorkEdinburgh
Country England Scotland
Areas in our guide 5 9
Sights listed 61 119
Places to eat and drink listed 88 214
Places to stay listed 27 78
Theater venues in our directory 4 12
Eat, stay and theater entries reported step-free 26 35
Eat, stay and theater entries marked family-friendly 0 0
Character from sight types Outdoor-leaning (59% of 44 tagged sights are outdoors) Mixed (47% of 91 tagged sights are outdoors)
Suggested stay in our guide 1 to 3 days 2 to 4 days
Average high in July 21.5°C1 19.3°C2
Average high in January 7.3°C1 7.3°C2
Rain in a year (sum of monthly averages) 618 mm on about 116 days1 728 mm on about 128 days2
Sunshine in a year (sum of monthly averages) 1524 hours1 1448 hours2
Daylight mid-June / mid-December (calculated) 17 h 07 / 7 h 24 17 h 35 / 6 h 59
Dated events in our calendar 6 dated, from organizer pages 5 dated, from organizer pages
Weather station used Church Fenton Edinburgh, Royal Botanic Garden No 2
Between the twoAbout 162 miles (260 km) in a straight line. Fastest published train: 2 h 23 min3. Journey details

Climate: Met Office 1991-2020 averages, stored Oct 25, 2026. Each station sits in or near the region, not necessarily in the town, so differences of a degree or two or small rainfall gaps can come from the station rather than the place. Daylight is calculated from latitude, not a Met Office figure. Station notes: York: Church Fenton is the Met Office station page for the area around York (it lies south-west of the city, not in it); no station page for the city center was found.

Choose York if… choose Edinburgh if…

Choose York if you…

  • would rather cover a smaller place: our York guide lists 61 sights across 5 areas, against 119 across 9 for Edinburgh.
  • want walking, coast, parks or hills: 59% of the sights we tag in York are outdoor places, against 47% in Edinburgh.
  • are going in July and want warmer days: highs average 21.5°C at the York station (Church Fenton), against 19.3°C at the other.
  • want less rain: the York station (Church Fenton) averages 618 mm a year, against 728 mm at the other (different stations, see the note under the table).
  • have a short break: our York guide suggests 1 to 3 days, against 2 to 4 days for Edinburgh.

Choose Edinburgh if you…

  • want more to see around one base: our Edinburgh guide lists 119 sights across 9 areas, against 61 across 5 for York.
  • prefer museums, galleries, churches and other indoor sights: 53% of the sights we tag in Edinburgh are indoors, against 41% in York.
  • an evening at the theater is part of the plan: our directory lists 12 venues in Edinburgh, against 4 for York.
  • can give it longer: our Edinburgh guide suggests 2 to 4 days.

Each line appears only where our data shows a clear gap. The thresholds are listed under “How we write this”.

How many days each needs

  • Our York guide suggests 1 to 3 days; its sample plans run from half day to 2 days. York guide
  • Our Edinburgh guide suggests 2 to 4 days; its sample plans run from 1 day to 3 days. Edinburgh guide

These are our guides’ suggestions, not a rule. Add travel time between places: fastest published train 2 h 23 min.

Bank holidays (public holidays) are not the same in England and Wales and in Scotland, so a long weekend in one may be an ordinary one in the other4.

Plan both

These itineraries include both places:

York guideEdinburgh guide All itinerariesGetting between the twoWhere to go each month

Questions people ask

How far apart are York and Edinburgh?

About 162 miles (260 km) in a straight line between the region centers. National Rail publishes a fastest journey of 2 h 23 min.

How many days do I need in York and in Edinburgh?

Our York guide suggests 1 to 3 days; its sample plans run from half day to 2 days. Our Edinburgh guide suggests 2 to 4 days; its sample plans run from 1 day to 3 days.

Is York better than Edinburgh?

We do not rank destinations. This page shows where our data differs so you can match it to your own interests, season and time.

Can I visit York and Edinburgh on one trip?

Yes: A first week in Britain (7 days), Castles and countryside (6 days), Edinburgh and York by rail (5 days), Manchester, York and Edinburgh by rail (6 days) combine both.

Editorial note. We do not claim one destination ranks above another. There are no scores, no “best”, and no cost levels, because we hold no sourced price data. For prices, check each operator or venue.

Facts last checked Nov 1, 2026.

How we write this

  • Counts come from our own region guides (sights, eat and drink, stays) and theater directories. A “Choose … if” line appears only when the gap is at least: 1.25x and 8 sights; 10 percentage points of outdoor share; 1.5x and 5 theater venues; 1.5°C in July or January highs; 15% in yearly rain; 10% in yearly sunshine.
  • Character: outdoor-leaning at 50% or more of tagged sights outdoors, city-leaning at 30% or less, otherwise mixed. Tags come from the sight type (park, museum, church and so on) with a short list of overrides in src/data/weather-fit.json.
  • Step-free and family-friendly counts include only entries tagged on OpenStreetMap or a venue page; many entries carry no tag, so a low count does not mean low access.

Sources

  1. Met Office: Church Fenton, 1991-2020 averages (for York). Church Fenton is the Met Office station page for the area around York (it lies south-west of the city, not in it); no station page for the city center was found.
  2. Met Office: Edinburgh, Royal Botanic Garden No 2, 1991-2020 averages (for Edinburgh)
  3. National Rail: Visit York by train. table "Journey time"
  4. GOV.UK: UK bank holidays

Sights, places to eat and stay, suggested stays and events come from our York and Edinburgh guides, each of which cites its sources. Journey times are as National Rail publishes them, retrieved Oct 25, 2026, and are not schedules.

Related comparisons

All comparisons Where to go each month